Panel Builder System Integrator

PB-43-Carlo-logo-400.jpg

March 24, 2021

By Blake Marchand

Carlo Gavazzi is a global provider of automation components. With a 90-year history in the industry they have grown and innovated with the progression of automated manufacturing. The company is active in industrial plastics, packaging, food and beverage, material handling, agricultural industries as well as intelligent building solutions, water and wastewater, and mining. Their product range focuses on sensors, switches, and controls, including proximity, photoelectric, level and ultrasonic sensors, solid state relays, contactors, energy meters, power supplies, panel meters, as well as current, voltage, and phase monitors.

Here, Carlo Gavazzi’s Product Manager for Switches, Terry Harmon provides some insight into the differences between Solid State Relays (SSRs) and Electromechanical Relays (EMRs) and the applications that match their performance, as well as touching on trends impacting product development.

Harmon explained that for the most part in general applications the decision between SSRs and EMRs comes down to the comparison between up-front and long-term costs. SSRs have a longer life and require less maintenance, although they’re more expensive. SSRs also have no mechanical parts to wear out, a substantially longer electrical life, and better reliability.

Applications that favor electrical isolation during switching will favor EMRs, said Harmon, and machine designs that demand high-speed operation and a very long switching life will prefer SSRs.

With respect to performance differences Harmon explained that: “EMRs can withstand higher voltage and current transients providing more protection for the application circuit.”

“Generally, EMRs are not sensitive to EMI/RFI and so are not impacted by electrical fields or noisy circuits.”

“EMRs are typically available with multiple pole options (multiple sets of contacts), as many as four or more, which allows for the switching of more circuits simultaneously from a single relay.”

“Mechanical contacts offer lower switching resistance and the air gaps between them help to prevent unwanted current flow. Not having to contend with the Off-state leakage current and higher output ON resistance of SSRs gives EMRS complete electrical isolation.”

Along with longevity and reliability, SSRs don’t have contact bounce to create problems with digital circuits. Not having mechanical parts also means they wont inadvertently open or switch “when subjected to shock and vibration.”

They also provide accelerated switching in comparison to EMRs and with a lower power control consumption. “SSRs are compatible with most ICs without having to add additional components such as buffers or drivers.”

SSRs also have options for fine proportional output control to precisely match the power output to given requirements.

And because they’re not impacted by external magnetic fields, they’re frequently used in environments with magnetic noise. Although, Harmon noted, “Due to the amount of heat generated during operation, SSRs continue to require heat sinks to dissipate this issue and ensure proper operation and performance.”

Harmon noted that SSRs with integrated heat sinks are continuing to become more prevalent in the market.

When it comes to cost breakdown Harmon explained further that, “The decision becomes a choice of either immediate, up-front savings with EMRs or long-term, cost of ownership savings with SSRs. EMRs have a significantly lower production cost compared to SSRs, which translates to a more cost-effective solution from the initial purchase. However, because SSRs have much higher reliability and electrical switching endurance, they will continue to operate well after the end of life of EMRs and require much less maintenance and replacement. In other words, a customer will save more money over the life of a machine or equipment that uses SSRs.”

Harmon also touched on safety considerations associated with relays, explaining that, “SSRs do not have any contacts between which arcing can form, thus making them safer to use in hazardous environments. Some SSRs have zero-cross switching, which allows them to switch “OFF” AC loads at the point of zero load current, further helping to eliminate arc formation.”

“Solid State Relays do not offer galvanic isolation, which means that electrical circuits are not completely separated thus eliminating stray currents. Electromechanical Relays provide better circuit isolation so that signals can pass between them, but block stray currents caused by differences in ground potential or induced by AC power.”

Looking at broader trends for SSRs and EMRs, Harmon said the growing value of space savings in automation panels and cabinets has led to the development of smaller, slimline EMR and SSR models.

“SSR manufacturers are always looking to minimize heat generation with more efficient components used on the output,” he added, and as noted above SSRs with integrated heat sinks are becoming more popular.

“EMRs and SSRs with monitoring options are also growing in demand,” explained Harmon, “The Internet of Things (IOT) has created a need for relays with communication protocols. The benefit of this is data collection and remote access has become top priority for machine builders because it allows them to make informed decisions, react quickly to urgent issues and even prevent problems from occurring.”

For more information, visit www.carlogavazzi.com.

Changing Scene

  • Prev
EY Canada is pleased to welcome AFARA and its team of multidisciplinary consultants to the firm to ...
Rockwell Automation, Inc. recently announced that Tessa Myers has been named senior vice president, ...
Rittal Systems Ltd. has announced that its valued partner, Tusk Automation Inc. has been named a ...
We often hear that everything old becomes new again, which serves to highlight the importance of ...
Weidmuller Ltd. has signed a distribution partnership with Shelley Automation for the Ontario ...
Carlo Gavazzi (Canada) Inc. of Mississauga, ON, has appointed Dany Lavoie and Brett Horst to its ...
Omron Automation Americas announces RAMP Inc. as a new partner in its Certified System Integrator ...
Skilled tradespeople in British Columbia will benefit from a made-in-B.C. system to support and ...
Rittal Systems Ltd. is pleased to welcome their first Rittal Certified Systems Integrator of ...
Panduit Corp. recently announced the promotion of Marc Naese to Chief Commercial Officer. A ...


EY Canada Acquires Sustainability Consulting Firm, AFARA

EY Canada

EY Canada is pleased to welcome AFARA and its team of multidisciplinary consultants to the firm to deepen existing resources and expertise in sustainability, and environment, social and governance (ESG) services.

“Businesses around the world are now embracing societal change and sustainable development as road maps to long-term success — and we are excited to play a role in that journey,” says Kent Kaufield, Chief Sustainability Officer and ESG Markets Leader at EY Canada. “At the end of the day, sustainability is everybody’s business. With AFARA, we look forward to helping clients build resilient, sustainable companies and economies, while furthering the energy transition.”

Read More


Honeywell Appoints Robin Watson To Board Of Directors

 

Honeywell Robin Watson

Honeywell has recently announced that its board of directors has elected Robin Watson, 55, former Chief Executive Officer (CEO) of John Wood Group PLC, to its board of directors as an independent director.

Watson was appointed CEO of Wood in 2016 after serving as both chief operating officer and an executive member of the Wood Group Board of Directors since 2013. During his tenure as CEO, Watson led the transformation of Wood from an oil field services company to an integrated engineering and consultancy company, spanning a variety of growing end markets in energy and the built environment, with a focus on sustainable technologies. 

Read More


Modern Niagara Partners With Global Sustainability Platform Worldfavor

Modern Niagara

Worldfavor is a global sustainability platform, digitizing and automating the collection, calculation, aggregation and visualization for analysis and reporting of ESG data. Now, Worldfavor is proud to welcome Modern Niagara as a new customer. Modern Niagara is the first Canadian construction company to partner with Worldfavor.

“Worldfavor was founded to be the best platform for sharing, accessing and gaining insights from corporate ESG information. Worldfavor’s mission is to make sustainability mainstream and with that we offer solutions to accelerate sustainability through the value chain. Modern Niagara is the first Canadian construction company to partner with Worldfavor. 

Read More


 

SmartBag Grouping is Live at YVR

SmartBag Grouping

Brock Solutions is happy to announce that SmartBag Grouping has successfully gone live at Vancouver International Airport. SmartBag Grouping provides YVR a tool for managing their Manual Early Bag Storage. The tool uses real-time data and allows users to create groups for baggage based on criteria such as time, flight, and airline. Critical information is delivered to baggage handlers in the field when they need it, on their handheld device, or on an information display.

Baggage is handled more efficiently during loading, and tracking information can be shared with other authorized SmartSuite users. 

 

Read More


 


Just Like Before, Only Better! An International Application by WAGO

WAGO

High-rise buildings in France, tunnels in Switzerland, prestressed concrete ceilings in Germany – one source of their stability is wire products from Kehl in Baden-Württemberg. Badische Drahtwerke GmbH (BDW) supplies reinforcing steel mesh, reinforcement cages, lattice girders and many other rebar and reinforcement products to the region and neighboring countries.

When the machines used to produce lattice girders had to undergo a safety update, the engineers took advantage of the communication capabilities of an intelligent power supply from WAGO to improve process efficiency.

Read More


 

Product News

  • Prev
AutomationDirect has added more color choices for Direct Wire 1kV ALL-FLEX MTW/THHW heavy-duty ...
AutomationDirect has added SSP safety enabling switches, also known as “hold-to-run” or “dead ...
Long leadtimes for non-fused disconnects can strain your electrical installation, as this product ...
Allied Electronics & Automation recently announced five new suppliers with stock on ...
Coming soon! POSITAL’s LINARIX family of linear sensors will soon include a new series of draw-wire ...
The Omron Factory Drive Recorder offers users the ability to optimize their machine troubleshooting ...
Introducing the Revolutionary New MP8000 Bluetooth Enabled Overload Relay. This smart, ...
LAPP has introduced its ETHERLINE GUARD data monitoring device for data cables. This compact, ...
Two product versions have been added to Phoenix Contact’s portfolio of narrow surge protective ...
Siemens PBSI Sept1 GIF fire test
Kerrwil Publications Great Place to Work. Certified December 2019 - December 2020

538 Elizabeth Street, Midland,Ontario, Canada L4R2A3 +1 705 527 7666
©2022 All rights reserved

Use of this Site constitutes acceptance of our Privacy Policy (effective 1.1.2016)
The material on this site may not be reproduced, distributed, transmitted, cached or otherwise used, except with the prior written permission of Kerrwil