Taking a Phased Approach Makes RTU and SCADA System Upgrades Seamless and Cost-Effective


October 8, 2021

Utilities that are replacing their aging remote terminal units (RTUs) and SCADA systems are doing so to ensure system reliability, improve usability and enhance future scalability – taking advantage of technology advancements in data connectivity and remote management. But how a utility approaches such a project is critical to ensuring that their system upgrade will be seamless and cost-effective.

Those who adopt a phased approach give themselves an opportunity to thoroughly evaluate the new technology’s feature set and assess its compatibility with existing equipment, which is critical for the extended process of transitioning to new technology. It also helps with the integration of new features so that a utility can take full advantage of what their new system offers. Staging the implementation is also a smart capital move as it does not commit project dollars before a thorough evaluation and go-forward implementation plan can be completed.

Glades Electric Cooperative, a 16-substation distribution cooperative that serves the power needs of four counties in Southern Florida with over 2700 miles of power lines and 17,000 meters, recently faced this challenge as they began their process of replacing their RTU and SCADA networks. Despite being installed relatively recently in 2015, the current RTUs were not meeting Glades’ reliability requirements.

“We were experiencing partial loss of function in one of our substations,” said Jose Cordova, Engineering Operations Manager at Glades. “One of the RTUs had four feeders, and there were times they would not respond to commands consistently. We also had a recloser that was not operating properly.”

Compounding the issue was virtually non-existent technical support from their vendor despite paying a fixed annual service contract above and beyond the product licensing fees. “We had service tickets that were months old that were never resolved,” said Cordova.

A contributing factor to Glades’ difficulty in resolving their technical issues quickly was their vendor’s use of a proprietary communications system between their RTUs and SCADA.

“The communication between the devices was proprietary technology, and so we were unable to resolve the issues on their own,” said Cordova. “When issues arose at a substation, it required us to deploy personnel to sort out issues manually, which eliminates the remote management benefits the system is supposed to deliver.”

So when one of Glades’ RTUs in a substation failed completely in February 2020, they decided to search for a replacement from a new vendor.

The search for a new system

“We started our search for a replacement by surveying our system and establishing priorities based on what was not working or working less than optimally,” said Cordova.

Glades had three primary goals in mind with their replacement. Given the inconsistencies with their existing system, reliability was foremost in mind. Scalability was also a key criterion. They wanted a system that could grow with their network, which also meant the ability to integrate with peripheral devices at their substations. Finally, the new system needed to be user-friendly.

“Our typical substation has voltage regulators, transformers, and circuit switchers,” said Cordova. “We also have voltage regulators, capacitor banks, reclosers, and trip savers downstream. For maximum operability, we need all of these devices integrated into our SCADA system.”

Cordova added, “We have a team of nine, and not having to travel to update these devices saves us money, time, and most importantly, improves employee safety. We want to reduce how much time people spend directly interfacing with the equipment at our substations.”

Cordova attended a user symposium hosted by a leading substation automation provider, Pennsylvania-based NovaTech Automation, where he was introduced to the company’s Orion RTUs and SCADA systems.

“I attended a two-day class that included a demonstration of their system,” said Cordova. “I was able to work with some of their equipment and configure it, which was very informative. Having that kind of hands-on experience and access to product information enabled us to complete a thorough evaluation. One of the things we were impressed with was the intuitiveness of the Orion web interface.”

A stepwise implementation


Glades approached the replacement of their system in a phased, step-by-step approach beginning with the replacement of a single RTU. The idea was to connect an Orion RTU to their existing SCADA system to evaluate its performance and compatibility before making a more significant investment.

“We took advantage of the Orion RTU’s integrated online connectivity to serve up communications more efficiently,” said Cordova. “By typing the IP address of the new RTU, we could directly access it through a web browser to see the substation online.”

Based on this initial phase, Glades decided to move forward with a second RTU implementation.

About the same time, the second RTU was delivered to the next network location, a transmission station, the existing SCADA top-end failed unexpectedly, causing Glades to lose situational awareness at that location temporarily. Chronic technical support response time issues with the existing vendor-led Glades to decide to upgrade their entire system at this point – 16 substations and their SCADA top-end.

NovaTech addressed the need for situational awareness of the field through the SCADA system configuration. Devices in the substation serve up their own data on a graphic view. A top-end unit in the office governs all these units and allows a single viewpoint of the network without entering the IP address of each substation. To further improve efficiency, NovaTech installed an Orion SCADA server in the Glades’ IT room to act as a hub or data concentrator.  

Today, Glades is about halfway through their co-op wide RTU replacement having installed Orion units at seven of their substations together with a data concentrator. When completed, they will have replaced their RTUs in all 16 substations.

Collaboration for optimal configuration

According to Cordova, the implementation has been very smooth despite executing the upgrade while working under the constraints of the pandemic.

The project scope included product, configuration, assembly services, testing, and site commissioning.

For the project, NovaTech assigned an engineer to build the system from scratch while working closely with Glades’ technicians.

“Having an expert involved helps us considerably because it enables us to customize as we build,” said Cordova. “This ensures that we have the features we need to make our operations center’s life easier.”

Cordova adds, “As an example, we have added an overview page that gives us a view of the entire system in one glance, eliminating the need to scroll through multiple screens to see what has happened at any of our 16 substations. If there’s an alarm, the overview page shows you exactly what happened and where in a very easy-to-understand layout.”

NovaTech is designing a load management page that will help Glades decide which feeders to turn off in a blackout rotation response to a volt electric emergency. 

“With the latest advancement in technology, there’s so much more that can be automated. Many utilities are under-utilizing their systems simply by not turning on features that could eliminate manual interventions,” said Cordova.

“In our case, there was a lot of data that we could have been collecting that we were not,” said Cordova. “Bottom-line, we were simply not taking full advantage of what we had. So, this time, with the help of NovaTech, we have configured a much more useful and tailored product that also is much better supported.” 

A cautionary tale

The lack of customer support that Glades experienced prior to selecting NovaTech resulted in a sub-optimized system configuration that created unnecessary manual work for their staff and increased their exposure to product failures because of the lengthy vendor response times.

Compounding the issue was that their vendor was charging a support fee through a service contract in addition to a significant annual product licensing fee.  The support fee was charged as a fixed cost whether they serviced the technology or not.

With Glades’ new RTU and SCADA system, it is not only better configured to their needs providing more automation support and remote management capabilities, but there is no fixed support fee beyond the licensing cost. Glades pays for service only when they need it.

Stepping towards success

A technology upgrade is a significant project for a utility comprising configuration, assembly services, testing, and site commissioning.  It is critical for a utility to take the time to fully assess the compatibility of a new technology with their existing systems, fully exploit new features to reduce manual interventions, and ensure licensing and support fees are to their advantage. Addressing these needs through a phased approach can help ensure an RTU and SCADA system upgrade will be seamless and cost-effective.

For more information, visit www.novatechautomation.com.

Related Articles

Changing Scene

  • Converting Waves into Electricity with Automation Solutions by ifm

    Converting Waves into Electricity with Automation Solutions by ifm

    By developing wave energy converters, CorPower pursues the idea of converting waves into electricity. The challenge with wave energy is to design devices that are not only robust enough to survive the harshest ocean storms, but also capable of producing enough electricity compared to their size and cost. CorPower masters this difficulty with devices that are naturally transparent and protected in storms, and which produce about five times more energy per tonne of device than state-of-the-art solutions in the ocean. Read More…

  • ABB Completes Acquisition of Siemens Low Voltage NEMA Motor Business Q2

    ABB Completes Acquisition of Siemens Low Voltage NEMA Motor Business Q2

    ABB has recently announced it has completed its acquisition of the Siemens low voltage NEMA motor business. The transaction was originally announced August 11, 2022, and financial terms of the transaction were not disclosed. The business employs around 600 people and generated revenues of approximately $63 million in 2021. The acquisition of this business is part of the Motion business area’s profitable growth strategy. It strengthens ABB’s position as an industrial NEMA motor manufacturer, and it provides an even stronger platform from which ABB can better serve its global customers. Read More…

Sponsored Content
The Easy Way to the Industrial IoT

The way to the Industrial IoT does not have to be complicated. Whether access to valuable data is required or new, data-driven services are to be generated, Weidmuller enables its customers to go from data to value the easy way. Weidmuller’s comprehensive and cutting-edge IIoT portfolio applies to greenfield and brownfield applications. Weidmuller offers components and solutions from data acquisition, data pre-processing, data communication and data analysis.

Visit Weidmuller’s Industrial IoT Portfolio.

For a Multiplied Value Unified


During the last few years, the Excelpro Group has welcomed AIA Automation, Envitech Automation and Conrad Lavoie Electrical, all of which have become ‘Member of the Excelpro Group’.

It was with great excitement that in November of 2022, Excelpro announced that these three companies officially became Excelpro. This decision is part of a strategy to enhance the Excelpro Group’s brand in its market.

These companies already collaborate on various client projects. This merger brings together the complementary strengths of the employees and ensures a global synergy of the activities throughout the Group.

Read More

Service Wire Co. Announces New Titles for Key Executives

Bruce Kesler and Mark Gatewood have been given new titles and responsibilities for Service Wire Co.

Bruce Kesler has assumed the role of Senior Director – Business Development. Bruce will be responsible for Service Wire’s largest strategic accounts and our growing Strategic Accounts Team.

Mark Gatewood has been promoted to the role of Vice President – Sales & Marketing. In this role, Gatewood will lead the efforts of Service Wire Company’s entire sales and marketing organization in all market verticals.

Read More

Tri-Mach Announces the Purchase of an Additional 45,000 sq ft. Facility

Tri-Mach Elmira Facility

Recently, Tri-Mach Inc. was thrilled to announce the addition of a new 45,000 sq ft. facility. Located at 285 Union St., Elmira, ON, this facility expands Tri-Mach’s capabilities, allowing them to better serve the growing needs of their customers.

Positioning for growth, this additional facility will allow Tri-Mach to continue taking on large-scale projects, enhance product performance testing, and provide equipment storage for their customers. The building will also be the new home to their Skilled Trades Centre of Excellence.

Read More

JMP Parent Company, CONVERGIX Acquires AGR Automation, Expanding Global Reach

Convergix Automation Solutions has completed the acquisition of AGR Automation (“AGR”), a UK-based provider of custom, high-performance automation design and systems integration primarily to the life sciences industry.

Following Convergix’s acquisitions of JMP Solutions in August 2021 and Classic Design in February 2022, AGR marks the third investment in Crestview’s strategy to build Convergix into a diversified automation solutions provider targeting the global $500+ billion market, with a particular focus on the $70 billion global systems integration and connectivity segments. Financial terms of the transaction were not disclosed.

Read More

Latest Articles

  • Efficient Power Supplies – An Investment in the Future

    Efficient Power Supplies – An Investment in the Future

    In the search for a suitable power supply, the costs play a major role, alongside the technical requirements. The focus is often on the initial purchase price, while other potential costs that may be incurred during the operation of the power supply are not taken into consideration. In this blog post, we demonstrate why the decision to purchase a high-quality power supply is a profitable investment for your company, by taking a close look at all the costs involved. Read More…

  • Q&A with HELU: Oil & Gas Instrumentation Cables

    Q&A with HELU: Oil & Gas Instrumentation Cables

    Reliable data transmission is a must, even under the most extreme mechanical and environmental conditions such as those found in the oil and gas industry. Cables must be versatile to perform whether it is on a ship at sea or in a refining plant on land. Instrumentation cables are the backbone to keeping the industry’s sophisticated machines online and operating at peak performance. Regional Sales Manager Andrew Gill answers some of the questions he hears in the field regarding these low-voltage cables. Read More…